When shopping for knives the question you are likely to ask is whether it is a stamped or a forged knife. The straight answer to this question is that a forged knife is made from a single steel bar that is heated and forged into shape. A stamped knife is cut out from a large sheet of steel and heat treated to enhance durability.
Another aspect that brings a comparison between the two knives is the price differences that brings in the assumption that forged knives are of superior quality because of their high price. We can use this logic but not in all cases. Further differences are visible by considering the remarkable distinctions in their manufacturing process. In as much as forged knives carry more favor, professional at the restaurant and people at home sometimes have a problem choosing between the two.
Let us use a table to highlight the significant differences and after that follow it up with a detailed explanation about the two types of knives.
Forged vs Stamped Knives
They have a bolster
They have no bolster
Light In Weight
Bends When Used For Cutting Hard Materials
What are the Manufacturing Differences?
A forged knife is made from a piece of steel that has been heated and hammered into shape. A technique called the hot drop forging is used in the manufacturing of a forged knife. The technique allows the steel to sit on a furnace until it is red hot and pulling it out and shaping the steel into a knife. The latest technology makes the same knife using heat treatment before pounding into shape.
A stamped knife is cut out from a large sheet of steel. The blade of this knife undergoes tampering, finishing, and then hardening ready for use. Due to their thin design, they are flexible, lightweight and come with a bolster.
Features and Disadvantages of Forged Knives
The forging process makes steel stronger and more durable. The movement of molecules when forging is taking place takes away the flexibility of the knife enabling them to maintain their edges for quite some time.
Forging process gives the makers of such knives an opportunity to create bolsters that protects your hand and gives you a comfortable grip when using the knife. This feature is distinctive to forged knives that you can use to identify a forged knife.
It is easy to sharpen a forged knife due to its flexibility, and it will not bend or twist when sharpening or holding it against a hard surface when cutting.
There are few disadvantages when it comes to forged knives other than the difficulty in using it to cut thin slices, and the price will discourage you. Forged knives are expensive, but if you are looking for a long-term solution in your kitchen, then there is nothing to lose.
Features and Disadvantages of Stamped Knives
Most stamped knives do not seem to have a reputation as big as the forged knives through the debate largely depends on facts or preferences. They are affordable and a good choice if you are on a budget especially if you need many knives for different uses, then stamped knives will work for you.
The first disadvantage of a stamped knife is that they do not undergo the forging process and hence are less durable and will not keep an edge for a long time. When using a stamped knife, your hands will have no “safety zone” hence you may cut your hand if not careful.
Stamped knives are not easy to sharpen using a whetstone because of their flexibility unless you are using an electric sharpener. Stamped knives are good if your work demands a flexible tool for boning and slicing fillets.
You may love to read: How to Shred Cabbage in Four Different Ways
The process of forging a knife is expensive and, but that does not mean that such knives are quality. With the changes in technological space, it is also easy to find a stamped knife that has better quality than the forged ones. You should also note that many knives are produced using a combination of forging and stamping.
Which One Should I Buy?
Most knife choices depend on how it feels on your hand and comfortable you feel when using it. A forged knife may be weighty, and you will sense some balance when handling it. Some people still prefer a lighter choice.
Blade Retention: how long do you want your knife to stay sharp? Make this judgment by holding the edge. Traditionally forged knives tend to pass this test with ease
Brands: you can also inform your decision based on brands reputation, however, do not fall for the name alone, which may not directly indicate quality. It is not a bad idea to look for brands with low-end offers.
Budget: if you want something economical, then a forged knife will do the trick. The blade thickness offers more durability and of course the bolster. Using a stamped knife may be prone to breakages because of the thin blade.
Also read: What Does Mahi Mahi Taste Like?
Depending on your preference, whether you like the weight in your hands as well as a firm study feeling on your hands, then your choice is already forged. Having a comfortable weight while cutting means less pressure when cutting a hard substance. The thickness of a blade also enables you to rock on the cutting surface.
If the nature of work requires a firm blade when navigating through the cutting surface, then make sure you have a forged knife nearby. However, many chefs and experienced cooks will tell you that the light weightiness of a stamped knife helps reduce fatigue when working for extended hours. Their thin blades cut through with ease.
There is a claim that stamped knives do not have strong edges like the forged knives, arguably this has to do with the materials used and maintenance methods in place. If you want a knife for the regular kitchen, then a stamped knife is good enough.
Kindly share with us, which knives do, you use, share your experiences using the comment section below.