The 10 Best Pizza Peel in 2023 – Detailed Buying Guide
When raw dough has to be transferred from the counter and into the oven, care needs to be taken not to destroy the shape of the creation. That’s why if you take a trip to your nearest pizza parlor, chances are that you’ll encounter a paddle-like device used for the job.
That paddle-like device is the subject of your conversation today as we explore the best pizza peel models in the following review.
Please note that pizza peels are also commonly known as baking peels. And as long as you love making pizza at home, they are indispensable tools to have around.
Top 10 Pizza Peel in 2023 – Comparison List
Making pizza in your home is about to become even more rewarding. Use the following list to zero-down to the ideal pizza peel for the money.
1. Honey-Can-Do Kitchen Supply Aluminum Pizza Peel
When it comes to Pizza Peels, we believe that this model by Honey-Can-Do is the best that you will come across in the market. It is lightweight, has an aluminum head and an 8-Inch wooden handle to keep your hands at a safe distance from the oven’s heat.
Product Description
The Kitchen Supply Pizza Peel is made in the USA, and it measures 16 by 18-inches. The head is made out of aluminum material which has rounded corners and is lightweight and sturdy at the same time to comfortably handle the big pizzas around.
The eight-inch wooden handle will help you to remove the pizza quickly from the oven without burning your hands.
Other Features and Benefits
This Pizza Peel has reinforced handles, and this enhances its stability. It has sturdy construction to ensure that it serves you for a long time to come and will not break apart easily as you remove the big pizzas from the oven.
This tool will help you avoid destroying the structure of the pizza, which is common when you use the hands for the same purpose.
Lastly, when you match its price with the quality of performance you are getting, you will realize that you have landed one of the biggest bargains ever.
Pros
- High-quality construction
- Well-priced
- Lightweight and easy to use
Cons
- The dough tends to stick to the head
2. Pizza Royale Large Ethically Sourced Premium Natural Bamboo Pizza Peel
The outstanding feature with this Pizza Peel is its bamboo construction. This is because the material has natural disease-resistance and is also very sturdy, lightweight, and minimum deep knife grooves. You will also be impressed with its versatility, and you can use it like cheese or bread cutting block.
Product Description
The ethnically sourced natural bamboo pizza peel comes with a sturdy handle that is light and has an excellent grip. The contoured design on the handle leaves a good feeling in the hands, and you will enjoy holding the tool for long periods.
It is easy to clean and will not split easily if you take good care of it.
Other Features and Benefits
The set features a pizza cutter with a stainless steel wheel and a premium bamboo handle to assure you that it will last for a long time to come. Then, it has extremely sharp edges to make slicing through pizza to be an easy process.
There is also the rolling pin which is stylish, large and you can use it at home or your restaurant for commercial purposes.
Pros
- Eco-friendly Bamboo construction
- Tough and durable
- Easy to clean (Hand-washing)
Cons
- The peel is not smooth
3. Chef Pomodoro Aluminum Metal Pizza Peel
If you are looking for a sturdy and versatile Pizza Peel, this Aluminum Peel by Chef Pomodoro would be an excellent place to start. The head is crafted from commercial grade aluminum and will take a lifetime to experience warping. Besides pizzas, you can also use this reel to remove cakes and bread out of your oven safely.
Product Description
This peel has an aluminum head measuring 12 by 14-Inches, plus a 10-inch handle which is foldable and will make storage very easy. The 10-inch handle creates a safe gap that will prevent the oven from burning your hands. The head is detachable, and this contributes to making it dishwasher safe.
Other Features and Benefits
Whatever the size of your kitchen, this pizza peel will fit in comfortably due to its foldable design that minimizes on space.
Then, the head has a safety back step that is a feature meant to prevent nasty accidents from happening.
It is a multi-purpose tool that would be a great addition to any kitchen.
Pros
- Durable aluminum construction
- Easy storage design
- Has safety back-step feature
Cons
- Produces a mildew smell which may be annoying to some
Read More: Stainless Steel Rice Cookers
4. Heritage 22 by 14-Inch Acacia Wood Pizza Peel
If you love making big pizzas, this pizza peel from heritage Products would fit the bill. Crafted from high-quality wood, this pizza reel, it is thick enough not to experience warping, and the tapered edge design will make it extremely easy to swoop under your pizza to remove it from the oven.
Product Description
The Heritage Acacia Wood Pizza Peel is made in the USA and is constructed from natural Acacia wood to make it durable and give it a lovely look. It has a tapered edge for easy swooping of the pizza from the oven, while the handle is ergonomic and will fit nicely in your hands. The head is smooth to ensure that the pizza slides off easily on to your serving plate without having pieces getting stuck on it.
Other Features and Benefits
This pizza peel has a convenient size that allows it to accommodate pizzas of different sizes, from small to medium and even the large pizzas. Its thickness will not affect the ease with which it slides into and out of the oven with a pizza.
It is a multi-functional tool that apart from using it as a serving tool, you can use it as a form of decoration for your kitchen. The Acacia wood construction gives it an attractive design that you will never get tired of seeing.
However, you need to treat the surface with wood-safe oil to ensure that it maintains its slippery nature.
Pros
- High-quality construction
- Stunning appearance
- Multi-purpose tool
Cons
- The handle is too thin and may slip easily
5. Ironwood Gourmet Napoli 28214 Pizza Peel
If you are looking for a pizza peel that can withstand the highest oven temperatures, you should try this model from Ironwood Gourmet. It has a beautiful design, and the hardwood Acacia is durable to ensure that it lasts for a long time to come.
Product Description
This pizza peel is crafted from Thai Acacia hardwood that makes it sturdy and gives it a beautiful look. The head measures 14 by 14-Inches, and this means that it can handle pizzas of a wide range of sizes. It has a tapered edge that makes it easy to scoop and turn pizzas in the oven. Its thickness will ensure that warping rarely occurs on this peel.
Other Features and Benefits
This tool has a very attractive appearance due to the Acacia hardwood, which gives it contrasting colors. It will add to the aesthetic value of any kitchen or room.
It has a high density that makes it anti-bacterial. The edge is slightly slanted to make it easy for the pizza to slide off. Further, the board is coated with only food-grade mineral oil to make it very food-safe.
The handle is sturdy and has a broad base that gives it a good grip and ensures that it rarely slips from your hands.
Lastly, the gourmet will give you options when it comes to storage.
Pros
- Multi-purpose tool
- Thick/no warping
- Beautiful to look at
Cons
- Needs too much maintenance
6. The Ultimate 14” Aluminum Pizza Peel
Maybe you are used to having Pizza Peels that have pieces sticking on it or even falling to the sides during scooping. This Aluminum Pizza Peel from Love This Kitchen aims to solve this problem. It has an advanced design with tiny divots that minimize contact with the raw dough and also help in releasing it onto the stone.
Product Description
This pizza peel is designed for both professionals and beginners and aims to address the problem of pizzas sticking or falling off the sides. It features an aluminum paddle with a non-stick nano-ceramic coating that is food-safe. It has a back lip for preventing the pizza from sliding while the angled hardwood handle will keep your hands safely away from the oven heat.
Other Features and Benefits
Since the divots and nano-ceramic surface help in releasing the dough onto the stone, you will end up using less dough than with wooden peels. The use of less flour also means that it will need less cleaning as a form of maintenance.
The wooden handle has a convenient position at fifteen degrees and will help keep your hands safe from the heat.
Pros
- Non-stick surface
- Raised anti-slip lip
- Easy to clean
Cons
- The peel is too thin
7. Frederica Trading Bamboo Pizza Peel Paddle
Sometimes when you are looking for a particular tool in the market, it is its certification that captures your attention. With this Bamboo Pizza Peel by Frederica Trading, you will realize that it has outdone itself in getting certifications. From FSC, FDA, LFGB, and BSCI, all necessary boxes are checked.
Product Description
This Pizza Peel from Frederica Trading is made in the USA and is crafted from Bamboo material to make it sturdy and durable. It is a versatile tool that will also work as a cutting board and serving tray as well. It is eco-friendly and non-toxic and has a perfect size to be a must-have tool for your kitchen.
Other Features and Benefits
To start with, this Pizza Peel is long enough to keep your hands safe and short enough to give it a sense of maneuverability. The bamboo construction makes it eco-friendly and also very hard such that you can use it as a cutting board without damaging it.
Then, it is entirely non-toxic, and you can get this assurance from the various certifications that it has, including FDA, FSC, LFGB, and BSCI.
The beveled edges will give you an easy time in scooping the pizza from the oven. Lastly, it is available in two sizes to let you choose your preferred size.
Pros
- Non-toxic
- Sturdy and durable construction
- The Slanted edges make unloading the pizza easier
Cons
- The lip can be too large
8. American Metalcraft Aluminum 2814 Pizza Peel
If you are on a budget, the Aluminum Pizza Peel from American Metalcraft could be what you need. It is 28″ long, and the large blade makes it well-suited for handling large sized pizzas.
Product Description
This Pizza Peel is made in the USA and is constructed out of 14-gauge aluminum for sturdiness and durability. The aluminum blade measures 14 by 16-Inches and will comfortably handle large sized pizzas. The aluminum construction also makes it very lightweight and will be easy to use and clean. It features a 12” wooden handle to keep your hands at a safe distance from the heat in the oven.
Other Features and Benefits
To start with, the aluminum material makes it sturdy and durable, so you will never be bothered by cracking or warping.
If you dust it regularly with flour or cornmeal, pizza will always easily slide off the peel. Besides baking, you can use it as a serving tool too.
Pros
- Easy to clean
- Very affordable
- Comfortable handle
Cons
- Has extremely sharp corners
9. Stainless Steel Pizza Peel by Checkered Chef
As a chef, you should know that scooping the pizza from the oven is never easy as you can easily distort its shape, drop it, or even burn your hands. The Checkered Chef aims to make this work easy as it has a thin paddle that is easy to slide under the pizza. There are also several other reasons that we think should convince you to acquire this peel.
Product Description
This pizza peel has a stainless steel construction to make it sturdy, durable, and dishwasher safe. It also has a rubber handle which is foldable for secure storage. This handle, when extended, is long enough to keep your hands safely away from the heat of the oven. The hole at the end also enhances secure storage.
Other Features and Benefits
The stainless steel construction means that you do not have to worry about rusting, discoloring, or warping. Cleaning it will also be very easy.
The rubber handle is comfortable and offers a good grip. This is unlike the wooden handle, which creates an itchy feeling in the hands.
Lastly, it is available in two sizes; regular and extra large so you can choose your preference.
Pros
- Versatile
- Foldable and comfortable handle
- Easy to clean
Cons
- The handle is prone to melting
10. EXO Polymer Non-Stick Pizza Peel
If you own a pizza restaurant, then you must understand the frustration that comes with scooping and transferring a pizza on to a plate in the shortest time possible. This pizza peel by EXO aims to solve this problem. It utilizes the polymer seal coating to ensure that you pick up and drop pizzas with minimum hassle.
Product Description
The Non-stick Polymer Pizza Peel by EXO is made in the USA and is designed to make picking up a pizza from the oven and transferring it to a plate very straightforward. The polymer coating is very food safe while the plate is wide to hold large pizzas. It is crafted from natural wood and will withstand the highest temperatures.
Other Features and Benefits
The peel has a balanced construction that distributes the weight evenly on the plate. As a result, handling even the large pizzas will be very easy.
The wood construction features no toxins, and this makes the tool to be very safe for handling food. The handle is long and smooth for comfort and also keeping your hands from the heat.
Lastly, it has no weird smells and is very easy to clean.
Pros
- Balanced construction
- Non-toxic construction
- Easy to slide in the oven
Cons
- Too thick
The Buying Guide
What are the key factors to consider before buying a pizza peel? You might be wondering. Well, in our view, it’s always important to understand most (if not all) of the details that matter. In particular, it’s quite important to pay attention to the following factors.
Materials
Pizza peels are made of different materials. Wooden ones are the most common ones although aluminum and stainless steel ones can also be found.
Wood
The wood material is a great option especially if you’re looking for something affordable. However, not all types of wood are ideal for this role. Therefore, your best bet is to go for a material that can withstand high temperature and provide support to your food.
The bamboo material is one of the best known ones for the job. But even the best made wooden peels require special attention at all times. So, be sure to have them cleaned with a detergent after every week – plus they should be left to dry properly after each cleanup session.
Metal
When it comes to metallic pizza peels, the two best materials you should think about are aluminum and stainless steel. The good thing with metallic peels is that they are highly durable. They are also easy to clean and maintain.
On top of that, they are thin which makes them easy to slide underneath your pizza. Unfortunately, wood is a poor insulator compared to wood. As such, there is an increased likelihood of the dough to stick to the peel.
Composite Material
These kinds of pizza peels are commonly made from a combination of resins and wood. The good thing with this kind of combination is that it boosts the strength of the wood and prevents flaking.
Also, composite peels tend to be thinner than wooden ones which means that they can easily slide beneath the pizza easily. Unfortunately, these peels also tend to have shorter-than-average handles which makes them less appealing to high volume operators.
The Length of the Blade
As far as the length of the blade is concerned, we’d suggest that you consider the depth of your deck oven. Ideally, the blade of your pizza peel is one that easily reaches the back of your oven when your hand is still several inches away from the opening of your oven.
You generally want a long handle so that it can prevent accidental burns. It also protects you from any messes that are likely to arise when you get physically too close to the pizza when cooking.
Size and Shape of the Blade
This is yet another extremely important factor to consider. That’s because, ultimately, the pizza sits on the blade. Some people opt for round blades while others prefer rectangular ones.
What you need to know is that the size and shape you choose can determine the size of the pizza you can lift on it.
Generally, round shaped peels are known for being easier to use especially when it comes to turning the pizzas. On the other hand, rectangular blades are loved by those who cook wide pizzas and want the widest platform available.
Which One Is The Best?
The Honey-Can-Do Kitchen Supply Aluminum Pizza Peel is in our view the best there is on the markets currently. It’s well-made, durable and just thin enough to easily slide beneath the pizza. It’s also affordably priced.
The fact that it’s rectangular makes it a perfect bet for anyone who might be preparing a large pizza. Unfortunately, it’s not the best for turning pizza owing to this shape although this doesn’t seem like a big deal to thousands of people who have reviewed it on Amazon.
Final Thoughts
Do you love your pizza? Then you’ve got to invest in an affordable pizza peel that you can love as well. With that said, we hope that the tips and tidbits provided above will help you make the right find today.
